Monday, August 6, 2012

Alaska Airlines and Blatant Discrimination

A few friends sent me emails about a story that has generated online buzz. Multiple stories have appeared in various mainstream news outlets as well. Alaska Airlines has been accused of discriminating against an elderly man with a disability and his friend. The source of the story is from Facebook--a fellow passenger who was outraged by what took place. Below is the raw Facebook post. 

 I request a complete and thorough review of the actions of staff today.. at the Redmond Oregon Airport. Cameron Clark reports, from the Redmond, Oregon Airport today.. """"i witnessed today, what i consider to be the worst of humanity.
standing in line at an @alaska airlines ticket check in, in redmond oregon, i watched as a disabled/mentally and physically challenged couple were left standing in the front of a line by the ticket attendant, melissa, who didn't say a word- no "final call, redmond to seattle"-- no "if you are flying to seattle, it's too ... 
late to make this flight," etc-- nothing. 
when a different agent appeared 1/2 hour later-- the flight still had not left. i asked for a quick "side bar" with the new agent-- telling her that this couple needed some leeway-- some additional help. she quickly informed me that "we treat every single customer the exact same here"-- she was annoyed by my insistence and advocacy. i tried to explain to her that her colleague had left the man and his companion alone, without saying a word to them. that they were "different" and that it would be ok for her to make exceptions for them (uttering something like, "exceptional circumstances sometimes require, exceptional responses").
melissa finally agreed to try to get the man on the flight-- but he couldn't bring his luggage (ug).
he had a hard time walking-- no one offered him a wheelchair or asked how they could be helpful. he stumbled off toward the safety inspection line.
predictably, he didn't understand/comprehend their restriction of his luggage, and got stuck in security. 
while this was going on, the ticket attendant and myself were continuing to have quiet words about how they needed extra help-- she told me that "i didn't know the whole story"-- that he had the "same problem yesterday, showing up late to his first flight." i told her that i thought there was a real reason he was struggling to make it anywhere on time, and that this was cause for some compassion and some exceptions to rules, and some additional assistance. by now i was fully annoying her. she had her rules, and she was growing tired of my moral compass.
security ended up sending the man back, telling him in the confusion around his luggage that there was no longer enough time for him to make his airplane, without the plane running late.
the original attendant, melissa, returned, and lightly shamed the couple for being late for the second time in a row, telling them there was no way the man could get to bellingham before 9pm now.
the man and woman broke into tears. his "nervous system hurky/jurkyness" became profound. he begged her to help him. nothing.
i asked tiffany to go on with the kids, that i wanted to stick around and advocate for this couple for the 20 minutes i could and still make my own flight...
i asked the man for his name. "brent" he and his companion were easily 70 something. he was crying something fierce by now. i asked him what his condition was. he said he had late stage parkinsons, and that his companion had MS. 
i asked to speak to the on site manager- a man named "jim cook." jim listened to me politely tell him the story about the man with parkinsons, and the woman with MS, and how none of his staff did anything to offer them additional assistance when it was clear to all 20 of us in line, how much they needed it and deserved it, and then he explained to me that the "laws don't allow alaska airlines to provide anyone, for any reason "special treatments." i wrote that comment down, word for word. he responded by saying, "so great, you are going to take me completely out of context aren't you?" i said, "what other context is there?" i asked you why your staff didn't help these people, and, in that exact context, you backed up your employee who told me that everyone is treated exactly alike. he stood by this position.
the end of this story is sad to the core. after wrapping up with mr. cooke, i talked to brent for a bit longer. 
this trip- redmond to seattle/seattle to bellingham, was allowing him to see his daughter one final time, who works on the ferry system and is out on the water for most of her time-- she was scheduled to meet him in bellingham at 3pm today. he said that it was a "bucket list" item that he could no longer realize. i asked him if she could get off the ferry and wait for him tomorrow-- and he said that she was only available for this brief time today-- that he was to join her on the ferry, and that otherwise she'd be out on the water for days-- his trip was done. he couldn't re-schedule. he was simply, now, in defeat, asking for his money back.
what part of this story is "ok" in any way?
what happened to our collective sense of decency, of compassion, of our disposition to help those in need of extra help.
alaska airlines. you broke a man's heart today. you maintained your policy, and ignored an opportunity to do the right thing.
you broke my heart too.
if i knew who to contact, i would contact them and invite them to pay for this man's daughters unpaid leave, and provide her a ticket to come see her father? short of that, i know of nothing that could undo the inhumanity i witnessed today.
blech.


I have no doubt this is an accurate description of the incident. It would in part reflect my experience every time I fly. Airline personnel are routinely rude to people with a disability. When I show up at a gate I do not even need to utter a word--the gate agent sees me as nothing but extra work and a hassle to deal with. When I fly I have the plague. Using a wheelchair and flying is a miserable experience. If I am lucky and all goes smoothly I will only be delayed about an hour. If things go wrong, and they often do, much worse things can happen than just being delayed. With this background in place nothing reported above is a surprise. What is a surprise is the reaction--over 42,000 people have noted they like this story and are upset with Alaska Airlines. This will surely sound like sour grapes but where are all these out raged people when I fly and get treated like dirt by airline personnel?  I cannot think of a single incident when I was supported by a fellow passenger. Once every few years a passenger will look at me as they pass and say something to the effect they are sorry I am being treated so badly.  This summer as I waited and waited and waited for assistance well after every passenger exited the plane the pilot for the next flight looked at me puzzled and asked "Are you still waiting?" Yes, I replied. He said "You guys who use wheelchair really have it rough" and then entered the cock pit and closed the door.  

The point of my two stories is simple and will negate the sour grapes aspect of this post: when one observes an injustice speak up. Offer your support. Take the risk and tell airline personnel you are offended by the way a fellow passenger is treated. And I know this is a risk. When people fly once they enter an airport thanks to the Patriot Act they give up their civil rights. All people must endure the humiliation ritual performed by the TSA. I get crowds need to be controlled. I get people have to get from point A to point B. I get airlines need to operate efficiently and maintain rigid control of passengers. Within this structure however the rights of people with a disability can be respected. When I assert those rights I am not liked--I am deemed a "problem". Perhaps if other passengers supported me and the airlines realized this would occur my rights might not be violated in the first place. I might even be treated with respect. I hope one day to have this sort of experience.

13 comments:

Phil Dzialo said...

Here is one of the most piss-poor responses to a human who was treated with indifference and profound neglect ... that an airlines could even respond with these words epitomizes the height of arrogance. Why do I feel that things never get better?

http://www.cbsnews.com/8301-201_162-57487174/alaska-airlines-fliers-post-sparks-online-backlash/

Matthew Smith said...

I Googled the story and found that the airline tried to smear the elderly man by claiming he smelled of alcohol -- something the man who posted the original FB account of the incident says he never noticed while standing with him for fifteen minutes.

william Peace said...

Phil, The airlines are disgraceful in that they have fought every effort to improve access for people with a disability. There is an ingrained bias that appears to be encouraged. Any request regardless of how trivial is met with stiff resistance.
Matthew, The smear tactic is a classic response. I filed a complaint with the DOJ against Northwest Airlines years ago and was stunned they out right lied about what happened. I realized any formal complaint was a waste of my time and effort. I have what I call the 1,000 mile rule. I only fly if the distance is greater than 1,000 miles. Anything less and I drive. It is cheaper and less stress.

Catherine said...

I've seen it happen twice. The last time I flew, the airline lost someone's wheelchair. Yes, wheelchair. And denied ever having it, when I personally saw the woman check it at the door of the airplane. Yes, I intervened, and yes, they were disgraceful. They did find the wheelchair but only after a big stink was made. They could not care less that the woman was missing her wheelchair. She did not get a tag for it as she should have when she turned it over at the plane door, and that apparently exempted the airline from any blame if it did not make the trip.

Another time, an elderly woman was left sitting for two days when flights were delayed and backed up. She was in a wheelchair and was not strong enough to get a seat on the flights as they were filled after hers was cancelled.

My MIL who is not a very together person was directed deliberately to the wrong flight--actually given a wheelchair ride to it once.

So, yes, I am fully aware that the airlines are disgraceful and even criminal about how they treat passengers.Ironically, this is one area where it is equal opportunity abuse.ANYONE a bit slow on the uptake or just not pushy is going to get the shaft anytime any service is needed or if something goes wrong. It behooves one to go early and start getting a complaint letter started, identifying all airline personele you come across, adding the abuses as they occur. I cannnot begin to list the cruelities that our family has undergone by the airlines.

Elizabeth said...

I've had a couple of horrible experiences FLYING WITH MY DISABLED YOUNG DAUGHTER so I don't have to imagine this happening to adults. I once wrote about it on my blog, and instead of getting sympathy, I was castigated by a couple of my readers. It was many years ago, but it still rankles.

I'd help you, Bill. I'd help you fight this, too.

william Peace said...

Catherine, Well, I am surprised to know support has been witnessed. Lost wheelchairs are not uncommon. Lost is really not the right word--stolen is more likely. I also agree the airline treats all people badly. I would suggest people with a disability are treated even worse than the average person.
Elizabeth, I am very surprised airlines were mean to a child. In my experience kids are treated quite well when they fly, especially when flying as an unaccompanied minor. I guess this does not extend to children with a disability flying with a parent or alone.

Catherine said...

I agree that airlines treat people with a disability much worse than an average person because they have a much higher likelihood of getting away with it.

I had quite the scene at the airport over my luggage--the tag they gave me was blank for the bag I turned over to them. I only got the tag because I asked for it and it was worth nothing as a receipt. The wheelchair was given nothing so when it did not show up, the airline was not on the hook. I have no doubt the personnel were doing this deliberately. I nearly lost the privilege of boarding the plane with the fuss I made over the blank receipt.

I'm sorry, Elizabeth. It hurts to think that anyone would treat a child poorly, and I cannot imagine how others gave YOU a hard time when you raised the subject.

Under the law a child flying alone has certain protections, from what I understand, up to a certain age. But one iota away for the letter of the law, and all bets are off. THey could not care less about the welfare of ANYONE including children is what my experience has been.

We need another Ralph Nader to hit them where it hurts. They were getting away with even more before he sued them and made policy such that the airlines at least have to suffer some of the pain of overbooking and other practices that they were doing to give themselves every benefit and leeway they could.

Becky said...

Wow. I had not heard this one -- this breaks my heart and is absolutely appalling. I will not fly on this airline and want to reach out to this couple. I am still working through my experience and so appreciated those who reached out to me. Your previous post on the Olympics is very thought provoking as well.

tigrlily said...

It annoys me that people think of providing equal access to folks with disabilities as "special treatment." Because the airline industry has become a mechanized process for moving product (people) from here to there with maximum efficiency, thus removing any trace of humanity, basic courtesy and respect has become "special" treatment.

But it's not "Special" it's a civil right to have access to air travel, and if that means the airlines have to make small modifications to their policies and practices, then they have to do it.

I understand the calculus involved in deciding how much of a stink to make at any given moment. It's a hard battle, and the airlines haven't had any incentive to do better. One or two successful lawsuits might do the trick, but who has money to sue?

Probably the best way to start is to carry hidden cameras (pen cameras are pretty unobtrusive) when we travel to record the outrages. That way we can use the evidence either in a public relations attack or to support a legal action.

Hassan Ashraf said...

great blog ever for information about airlines i personally like it very much,your work is very impressive and information is also fantastic,true and genuine.best of luck!
Airlines Contacts

Cake-Pie said...

Flying doesn't always suck for me (I was treated phenomenally well by Jetblue many times) but like anyone who travels with a handicap it seems like we should expect trouble.

I'm a part-time wheelchair user, but I always need a chair for everything when I fly. At the end of a flight I was still on the plane and a flight attendant asked me to take my bags from overhead. I said "I can't do that I'm disabled" and she looked at me disgusted and said "Well it's not my job to get those for you". Usually it's a long wait to get off the plane for me as well but this time it was longer because I had to wait for an undisgusted person to help me get my one small bag from overhead.

You mean to tell me they can't just get up and walk off the plane anytime they like? How hard would it really be to train people to think about this for one second?

It's also worth noting that I haven't flown with the new backscatters and increased security theater. I imagine it's a special hell.

william Peace said...

Cake-Pie, Jet Blue and Southwest are the best airlines for people with a disability. I would say that these two airlines at least try to the best they can. Delta is without question the worst. I would never fly Delta.

Calvin Brock said...

Hey – great blog, just looking around some blogs, seems a really nice platform you are using. I’m currently using WordPress for a few of my blogs but looking to change one of them over to a platform similar to yours as a trial run. Anything in particular you would recommend about it? airtran credit card